Monday, February 04, 2013

Why Public Transport Beats Airport Taxis

Such a minivan is almost always bloody crowded, but almost 90 times cheaper than a taxi ride to Antananarivo. 

It is often convenient to take a taxi to or from the airport. But there are in my opinion also reasons why you should rather pick public transport. At least eleven of them. 

1. Taxis are almost always more expensive than public transport. That doesn't necessarily mean that taxis are expensive. To take a taxi to or from Antananarivo from Ivato International (TNR) only costs 16 USD, but that is still 87.5 times more than the cheapest public transport option. To or from Newark outside New York, the difference is only 3.75 times. See more examples at the bottom of the article. 

2. Public transport often actually saves you time. In many cities with dedicated train or tram lines, taxis are slower or much slower due to traffic and a longer travelling distance thanks to more turns and hills. The Maglev Train from Pudong International Airport in Shanghai has a top speed of 431 km/h. Unfortunately it stops a little outside the town centre, so you will in most cases have to take a taxi anyhow. Travelling that fast by train is still definitely worth it! The speedometer is visible from all seats, as a bonus and a photo op.

3. If you take a taxi, it is you and your driver. You will not meet anyone else. In a bus or a train you meet new people and get an early introduction to your destination and the culture there from your fellow travellers. If nothing else just by seeing them or overhearing conversations. But you can always be a little more adventurous and ask someone for recommendations.  Most locals are more often than not eager to tell you about their area or country. 

4. Public transport will rarely take you exactly where you are going, as opposed to taxis. You think that is a bad thing? I disagree as long as I am not in a rush. It gives you the possibility to explore a new area on your way to your accommodation, a great way to discover shops, cafes or restaurants that you may want to revisit later. Not to mention the excercise. Keep fit between all those trains, planes and automobiles. 

5. Buses and trains in more and more locations offer free Wi-Fi zones on board to attract more passengers. That gives you a great opportunity to as early and cheaply as possible update your social media statuses or check on your mails.
6. Bus or train drivers won't fool you by taking a detour or overcharging. They follow their schedules. 

7. Taxis don't offer refreshments. Some buses and trains do.

8. There are no toilets inside taxis. It may not usually matter, although it will certainly be essential if you have run into food poisoning on your journey.

9. Public transport is a greener alternative. Al Gore will be proud of you. 

10. You can't walk around in taxis. You can in metros, buses and trains. Unless it is rush hour in Tokyo, Asmara or Mexico, of course. Being able to move may be much wanted after 14 hours in a cramped economy seat.

11. The pressure to tip a taxi driver is much higher than to tip a bus driver. If you give in, the price goes up even more. If you don't, expect a nasty look or a colourful oral reply.

Comparative costs

I earlier mentioned comparative costs between taxis and public transport. So, what is the taxi – public transport price ratio, given that you travel alone? Examples follow below. Among them are Antananarivo in Madagascar where it costs almost 90 times more to go by taxi than to go by bus. That is the biggest difference that I have discovered, although it doesn't mean that taxis are expensive. It only costs 16 USD, going by bus is just dirt cheap.  And many of the taxis in Antananarivo are very cool and worth taking. Old Citroens or Renaults will take you back in time. 

Any better or worse examples from around the world? Please share your comments below. 

Ivato International Airport (TNR) – Antananarivo

Taxi: 35,000 MGA
Shuttle bus:14,000 MGA
Bus: 400 MGA (requires you to walk 150 meters from the terminal)
Ratio: 87.5 (times more expensive by taxi)

Schipol (AMS) – Amsterdam

Taxi: 48 EUR
Train: 3.90 EUR
Ratio: 12.3 

London Heathrow (LHR) – London

Taxi: 60 GBP
The Tube (metro): 5.50 GBP
Ratio: 10.9

Oslo Gardermoen Airport (OSL) – Oslo

Taxi: 890 NOK (if you use the right taxi company and ask for a fixed price in advance – otherwise you may pay double or even more)
Airport express train: 170 NOK (half price for kids, students and the elderly)
Airport bus: 150 NOK (80 NOK for kids, students and the elderly) 
Ratio: 5.9 

Newark (EWR) – Manhattan

Taxi: 60 USD
Shuttle bus: 16 USD
Ratio: 3.75


Any better or worse examples? Please share below. 


47 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I totally agree. I always travel with cabin luggage only, so it's just as easy to take public transport. One place I travel to regularly is Warsaw, Poland. From Warsaw's main airport to the city centre is about 45-50 zloty, compared to just 3.60 zloty by train.

    Last year I wrote an blog post about getting to the airport in Melbourne (where I live) cheaply on regular public transport which is even cheaper than the dedicated airport bus, but which is kept as secret as possible by the airport authorities - here's the link: http://aerohaveno.blogspot.com.au/2012/03/to-melbourne-airport-cheap-arse-way.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. Federalfulfillment.com is a company focusing on item fulfillment package and provide and wine fulfillment. We are your most valuable partner when it comes to making smart and successful company choices. We have proven, reliable and encounter fulfillment solutions located in the Area. Our vast encounter, several places and versatility to include with your techniques create us one of the top satisfaction organizations in the Area. Federal Fulfillment houses increase our supply sequence solutions from e-commerce to products fulfillment.

    Federal Fulfillment houses are devoted to offer a variety of personalized solutions that meet the specific needs for fulfillment. Our solutions are a affordable way to quickly and perfectly process your purchases. We have ability to innovate and provide functional quality can be found at the heart of the fulfillment website's achievements. Our Federal Fulfillment houses offer to customers a confirmed understanding into the complicated nature of delivery and receiving the right way to do it. We have full provider for advertising fulfillment solutions and offer a number of additional solutions such as warehousing, Midwest fulfillment, pick and package and more.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Classic Autos for Sale
    Used autos for sale are available in numerous models, styles along with manufacturers, beginning with the actual domestic automobiles towards brought in kinds. In addition, they present great many varieties of selections towards finish advantage of the actual possible automobile customers. The particular applied autos for sale sellers present customers an incredible various domestic along with brought in automobiles in incredible savings. That they take cheap deals in second-hand cars almost frequently to help customers very own the actual automobiles for an economic budget. Motor vehicles will help you with every aspect regarding studying a used car to acquire. Utilize our progressive assessment tools, which include photo review, to check out opponents along with ensure that you have made the correct choice.
    Classic and Muscle Cars
    Classic and Muscle Cars can be thought as high-performance autos using highly effective machines, nearly all created in between 1964 in addition to 1975. It will take a clear kind of particular person your can purchase a genuine muscle mass car as well as classic car. It’s just not a car for many years. It’s a lifetime dedication as well as a appreciation. These individuals are thoughtful into attend to their own autos in addition to accept just the most beneficial remedy in addition to providers.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Citytaxidispatch.com aims to offer you with first-class Taxi Berkeley Ca solutions. We have completely climate-controlled cab taxis or shuttle service, and all our motorists have 23 years of experience and know the best tracks to get you to your location on time. All of our motorists are qualified and helpful. Our certified motorists are among the best. We endeavor to offer excellent client support during local and Terminal exchanges. While driving our Taxis in Oakland, you will appreciate and advantage from the newest designed personal solutions. Our exclusively qualified Taxi Cab Service assistance providers focus on assistance demands based on the transaction in which they are obtained, the vicinity of a Taxi Service for cab to a call, and by any specific need like wheel chair accessibility or high-occupancy.
    With 24-hour, 365 days-a-year stay client solutions and a State-of-the-Art electronic delivery with built-in GPS in every Taxi Services to Airport, you can discuss to a real person to perfectly and effectively purchase your Berkeley Cabs. Through our website, you can purchase and source a cab, calculate your stand up and even monitor your journey.

    These days, by adhering to our beginning concepts, we now have more than 220 unique yellow-over-black taxicabs in assistance to Lemon Nation and we're still increasing. We take our assistance expertly and we well-known for our better Taxi Service San Francisco Airport.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Availability for Auto transport services is quite a requirement for people who shift or transfer because of jobs or other needs. It looks as sign of great relief and comfort when an agency ensures for the safe and secure shipment of auto transport because executing such responsibility professionally is a serious affair.
    www.greatamericanautotransportation.com provides the service nationwide ensuring the safety of your precious vehicle. When a consumer thinks of shipping an automobile it is quite genuine to meet some underlined pre-requisites like – price, time consumed for the shipment, collection and delivery areas, and the condition of the vehicle when handed over. It targets convenience of providing service at door step.
    Having an integral service network all through the United States facility of domestic, interstate transfers are easily available for potential customers through outlets in American auto transport Denver; auto transport Florida etc.
    The vehicle shipping rates offered in Las Vegas are cheap and affordable which remains incomparable in the industry. So, if you have some requirement of car transport quotes all you need is to book and place order. The process starts by simply filling the available online form. It is the best auto transport company across the competitive industry.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This move is designed to improve all British airports and ensure that the two major ones can handle the traffic that comes their way every day.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Taxi's may be more expensive for some journeys but in London several survey's have been conducted that shows a relative increase in rail fares over chauffeured transport. One useful blog is found here at http://www.squidoo.com/public-transport-vs-luxury-chauffeur-car .If this is the way things are going with 'chauffeurs' offering cheaper prices and government backed rail fares increasing we are all doomed.
    Food for thought!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Link here for article to play devil's advocate here Public Transport vs Luxury Chauffeur Car

    If you look at the cost per hour wasted by business commuters in London taking public transport then these figures make sense to the largest commuting population.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The cars here RSS - London Chauffeur Driven Prices are more expensive than public transport. Unless you are looking at flying Concorde!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I disagree with you. When you are on your way to OR from airport you definitely have some luggage with you. And with that it is very troublesome to avail public transport.
    garden grove taxi

    ReplyDelete
  12. Get reliable and affordable cool cab service in Mumbai
    Call for booking cab service in Mumbai local or outstations service : +91 9664594482
    Visit: Rk Travels and find the best package on cab service for Mumbai-pune-nasik

    ReplyDelete
  13. I am very amazed by the data of this weblog and i am glad i experienced a look more than the blog. thank you so much for sharing these kinds of excellent information.
    atlanta airport limousine

    ReplyDelete
  14. With this blog you really took our attention to the points public transport that we never thought about. really public transport is better, it's save more time and money also. thanks for sharing this informative blog.
    Auto shipping quote Las Vegas

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks for nice sharing.You should remember the story of a group of youths in a taxi.. At journeys end they got ... Sometimes your luck is excellent, a run to the airport and you find someone on the way back into town straight away to see more..midway taxi If you are looking for a reliable and affordable airport taxi or transportation, we highly recommend that you use My Personal Taxi

    ReplyDelete
  16. Nice blog! Prague has a nice ratio: 27,1: By taxi it costs 650 czk/25 euro. By public transport (bus/metro) it costs 24czk/1 euro (for 30 minutes) or 32czk/1,25 euro (for 90 minutes, in case you want to take the touristic route)

    ReplyDelete
  17. Thank you for sharing this very nice post, please keep continue the sharing of this types of information. Here we are waiting for more

    ReplyDelete
  18. nice blog lots of information are there,
    for more visit:
    www.a4cars.co.uk

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think the main reason airport taxis are popular is because it doesn't require researching ahead of time and it's more convenient.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Such as other pursuits on the net, the world connected with commercial audio is also filled up with frauds. You would be shocked from the quantity of those who market unlicensed or compromised audio to unsuspicious individuals.
    beats for sale

    ReplyDelete
  21. While using the increasing desire with regard to pop songs, there exists a increasing desire with regard to pop painters, therefore, a developing desire with regard to pop surpasses available for sale. Suppliers everywhere tend to be recognizing this kind of trend, thus acquiring manufacturers who create pop surpasses would have been a very little less difficult compared to prior a long time.
    beats for sale

    ReplyDelete
  22. It is truly a great and helpful piece of information.
    I am satisfied that you simply shared this useful information with us.
    Please stay us informed like this. Thanks for sharing information.
    Get all points airport service

    ReplyDelete
  23. We professionally provide Airport Transportation from Bocaraton, Airport Transportation from Palm Beach, Airport Transportation near Bocaraton and Airport Transportation near Delray Beach.

    visit-http://www.whiteeagleslimo.com/

    ReplyDelete
  24. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  25. International car delivery firms supply personalized transport solutions intended for households along with experts shifting abroad. While choosing a global automobile transport firms, an experienced, encounter transport corporation using the suitable founded relationships constantly in place help to make this relocation method simpler.
    International Shipping

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thanks for sharing this informative post here but i fully disagree with your thoughts. Public transport cannot help you when travel with family and heavy luggage. At that time of trouble only Airport taxis are helpful for passengers they come at just one call and pick up from any location with luggage.They also charge reasonable prices which is less than private transport.So i think airport taxi are much better than public transport.

    ReplyDelete
  27. The advantage of using a airport taxi is that they know the area and you don't have to research bus schedules. For someone who moves around for work they're the better option.

    ReplyDelete
  28. great article, thanks for sharing

    ReplyDelete
  29. Thanks for sharing a good article about melbourne taxi. Good work.

    ReplyDelete
  30. The service was great. I called 1 hr. before I needed to be picked up to go to SJC. They picked me up on time, had a pleasant conversation with my driver, Sunny, and they take credit cards!!! Will definitely use them again. two thumbs up. Taxi Bristol to Heathrow Airport

    ReplyDelete
  31. Iam very impreased for this website. airport taxi If you are looking for a reliable and affordable airport taxi or transportation, we highly recommend that you use My Personal Taxi. We are serving the Chicagoland area for over 7 years. We can take you to the airport, the doctor, or wherever you need to go in a fast and efficient manner. We are very affordable and quality conscious people and we are the best alternative to buses, trains and shady transportation services.

    ReplyDelete
  32. I'm amazed, I have to say. Actually barely ever do I experience a site that's both educative and entertaining, and permit me notify you, you may well have hit the nail on the head. Your notion is excellent the problem is anything that not adequate folks are talking intelligently about. I am extremely joyful that I stumbled throughout this in my find for something referring to this.
    Hayward Airport Taxi
    Piedmont Taxi CA

    ReplyDelete
  33. Our company gives rubberized tracks from the breadth of 150mm for you to 800mm that are pertinent on different kinds of excavators, earthmovings, farming equipment plus the additional gadgets.rubber tracks

    ReplyDelete
  34. I didn't want to ask anyone for a ride because I know how it is after work - you just want to hurry the hell out to go home or wherever so I called Airport Taxi thanks to Yelp yesterday, got an immediate quote, got a confirmation call, and the guy was on time. Airport Transfers to Heathrow

    ReplyDelete
  35. Kigurumi are fun, cozy costumes and pajamas, perfect for a costume party! Wholesale kigurumi from distributor online. We have lots of animal kigurumis.monster costumes
    monster kigurumi
    monster onesies

    ReplyDelete
  36. You have disused the good points in your post and I liked the way of sharing. You have truly said that a taxi or luxury services can't meet to public transport according to price wise. But the points are that the person who can afford the luxury services why he would demand for the public transport. If we hire services than it will take you where you want to go but through public transport it's not possible. I tell you about the UKDriven they providing the most exciting transportation services throughout the London airports, Executive Cars London, Chauffeur Driven Cars London. The best thing in a UKDriven is that they deliver the promise.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Wie of wat u ook wilt (laten) vervoeren: personen, documenten of pakketten, Wie of wat u ook wilt (laten) vervoeren: personen, documenten of pakketten, bij Marcus bent u altijd aan het goede adres. Onze gestage groei danken wij aan een hoge mate van klanttevredenheid. Wie die eenmaal heeft ervaren, wil niet meer anders!
    www.marcus.nlbij Marcus bent u altijd aan het goede adres. Onze gestage groei danken wij aan een hoge mate van klanttevredenheid. Wie die eenmaal heeft ervaren, wil niet meer anders!
    www.marcus.nl

    ReplyDelete
  38. Airport Transportation From Palm Beach We professionally provide Airport Transportation from Bocaraton, Airport Transportation from Palm Beach, Airport Transportation near Bocaraton and Airport Transportation near Delray Beach.



    ReplyDelete
  39. You have a reliable information here in your site, however I am looking for more information regarding town car services in St. Louis.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Wie of wat u ook wilt (laten) vervoeren: personen, documenten of pakketten, Wie of wat u ook wilt (laten) vervoeren: personen, documenten of pakketten, bij Marcus bent u altijd aan het goede adres. Onze gestage groei danken wij aan een hoge mate van klanttevredenheid. Wie die eenmaal heeft ervaren, wil niet meer anders!
    www.marcus.nlbij Marcus bent u altijd aan het goede adres. Onze gestage groei danken wij aan een hoge mate van klanttevredenheid. Wie die eenmaal heeft ervaren, wil niet meer anders!
    www.marcus.nl

    ReplyDelete
  41. I like to get the details about the transportation facilities on Heathrow airport taxis

    ReplyDelete
  42. I really enjoyed the quality information you offer to your visitors from this blog. Thanks for sharing such an wonderful post with us...

    ReplyDelete